Eagle Hall of Honor
| #1 Bliss Curtis | 1929 | #43 Greg Polsdorfer | 1991 |
| #2 Elmer Lange | 1929 | #44 Mark London | 1992 |
| #3 Jack Arend | 1930 | #45 Mark Carmichael | 1995 |
| #4 Elvin Armbruster | 1933 | #46 Jeff Nadig | 1995 |
| #5 Warren Gross | 1933 | #47 Ryan Ticknor | 1996 |
| #6 Ray Hunt | 1934 | #48 Matthew Wheatley | 1996 |
| #7 Stanley Hartman | 1935 | #49 Chris Michalak | 2000 |
| #8 Charles Collins | 1936 | #50 Jason Hackbarth | 2000 |
| #9 Robert Clay | 1939 | #51 Michael Schultz | 2001 |
| #10 George Cook | 1944 | #52 David Heskett | 2001 |
| #11 Bruce Carr | 1960 | #53 Tom Stall | 2002 |
| #12 Joe Masterson | 1964 | #54 Andrew Wirth | 2002 |
| #13 Ron West | 1964 | #55 Marcus Schwimmer | 2002 |
| #14 Tom Masterson | 1967 | #56 David Katanski | 2002 |
| #15 Brian Singleton | 1972 | #57 Martin Kosla | 2003 |
| #16 Matt Vila | 1973 | #58 Matthew Wonsavage | 2003 |
| #17 Dan Lantham | 1975 | #59 Aaron Malocha | 2004 |
| #18 Mike Maynard | 1975 | #60 Kevin Novak | 2004 |
| #19 Gary Losey | 1976 | #61 Jon Norton | 2005 |
| #20 Daryl Singleton | 1976 | #62 Ryan Stegenga | 2005 |
| #21 Tom Dailey | 1977 | #63 Michael Capelli | 2005 |
| #22 Brian Graham | 1977 | #64 Alex Dowling | 2005 |
| #23 Bob Heskett | 1977 | #65 Joshua Richter | 2006 |
| #24 Art Saulsberry | 1978 | #66 Alex Van Hout | 2006 |
| #25 Joe Amador | 1981 | #67 Stephen Stump | 2006 |
| #26 Jim Graham | 1981 | #68 Daniel Shea | 2006 |
| #27 Elton Saulsberry | 1981 | #69 Joseph Orrechio | 2007 |
| #28 Rob Thompson | 1982 | #70 Branden Slagle | 2007 |
| #29 Larry Haeske | 1983 | #71 Nicholas Turosky | 2007 |
| #30 Mike Fedor | 1983 | #72 Jack Norgren | 2007 |
| #31 David Renner | 1983 | #73 Schuyler Orrechio | 2007 |
| #32 Daniel Thompson | 1984 | #74 Aaron Bolder | 2007 |
| #33 Erik Nadig | 1986 | #75 Jared Richter | 2007 |
| #34 Robert Haeske | 1986 | #76 Christopher Katanski | 2008 |
| #35 Mark Nadig | 1987 | #77 John Wright | 2008 |
| #36 Bradley Nadig | 1987 | ||
| #37 Jeff Thompson | 1987 | ||
| #38 Brian Ticknor | 1988 | ||
| #39 David London | 1988 | ||
| #40 Craig Greca | 1989 | ||
| #41 Mark Polsdorfer | 1989 | ||
| #42 Scott Greca | 1990 |
